Bengay or icy hot

[zenlife2000]

Which is best bengay or icy hot?

[heavenglories]

I think bengay is better.

[heavenglories]

I think bengay is better.

[dwiley11]

icy hot but both hurt on sensitive areas

[sharonpatri55]

Bengay has always worked the best for me; it's usually on sale more often, too.

[bettey13]

I use a product my husband found at the health food store called Super Blue Stuff, now I have to get it on line, but it's great!

[nmbrown863]

I have never used bengay but I have used icy hot many times and I think it works great. I have a store brand that works just as good too.

[yikes77]

I never really found icy hot works for me.  Bengay smells but works.

[dodgers16]

   although I think bengay does work better, I prefur to use Icy-hot because it does not have an oder while its on you

[sherryfan]

Icy hot, it works great for me

[vp44]

I think icy hot is better.

[davidh121]

Icy hot is okay, but I grew up with Bengay and the brand has been very consistent for family and myself. The product really bring tremendous relief when I'm sore.

[patycake56]

I honestly have to say that the icy hot has worked better for me

[cateyes1]

I tried both and I would say Bengay

[aflyingmonkey]

Try Blue Emu
They sell it online & at Target, Walmart, etc...

Works really well, without the smell.